Aluminium or steel fences
Aluminium costs more up front, but it does not rust and a scratch needs nothing more than a touch-up. Galvanised, powder-coated steel is cheaper and stiffer, but any damage that goes through the coating to the metal has to be sealed before rust sets in. Below we compare the two materials on durability, weight, cost over 10 years and design, and say which one suits which kind of house and plot.
Aluminium: pros and cons
Aluminium does not rust, although it does corrode: next to a road that is salted in winter, a white bloom can form on the coating, which is why it needs washing in spring and why coatings are given corrosivity categories. A scratch does not spread into the metal. Powder-coated profiles hold their colour for a long time and the whole fence is light, so sliding gates run more smoothly and put less strain on the gate motor.
- No rust: a good choice near woodland, water and salted roads, provided it is washed after winter.
- Little maintenance: washing once or twice a year is enough.
- Plenty of designs with horizontal slats and concealed fixings.
- Higher purchase price than steel, lower upkeep costs.
Steel: pros and cons
Steel fences (hot-dip galvanised and powder-coated) are rigid, mechanically strong and usually cheaper to buy. The coating does need watching, though: wherever a knock goes through to bare steel, rust eventually appears and creeps under the paint.
- Rigidity and a lower purchase price.
- Well suited to classic wrought-iron designs.
- The coating needs checking and touching up after every knock.
| Criterion | Aluminium | Galvanised steel + powder coating |
|---|---|---|
| Corrosion | Does not rust; scratches do not spread | Damage through to the metal can rust |
| Panel weight | Light: less load on posts and hinges | Heavy: stronger posts, larger foundations |
| Maintenance | Washing with water once or twice a year; next to a salted road, also after winter | Washing + checking for coating damage, touch-ups |
| Upfront price | Higher | Lower |
| Cost over 10 years | Practically just washing | Possible coating repairs; if neglected, full renovation |
| Design | Slats, panels, concealed fixings | Panels, palisades, wrought-iron designs |
| Long panels / solid infill | Rigid system profiles; post spacing to the manufacturer’s specification | Very rigid; copes well with solid infill |
| Who it suits | Houses with simple lines, minimal maintenance, close to salted roads | Tight budgets, classic architecture, long runs |
Paint finish and corrosivity categories
A powder coating, whether on aluminium or steel, is rated by the corrosivity category of the environment it is designed to withstand (a scale from C1 to CX under ISO 12944). Good aluminium systems pass salt-spray chamber tests and declare category C5, one of the highest; CX covers coastal and industrial sites with extreme salt exposure. For a plot on a street that is salted in winter, this category tells you more than the coating thickness in microns.
When to choose aluminium and when steel
For houses with simple lines and horizontal slat designs, aluminium usually comes out ahead: lighter panels, longer profiles without reinforcement, no touch-ups. For classic architecture, wrought-iron designs and tighter budgets, steel is often the more sensible choice. We install both; the material and system are chosen at the site survey, once we have seen the plot and the façade.
What you see after a few winters
The differences between the two materials show after a few winters. Scratched aluminium forms an oxide layer that protects the metal from further corrosion; a touch-up in the RAL colour is all it needs. Galvanised, powder-coated steel is durable, but any deeper damage to the coating (through to bare steel) is a spot where rust will appear in time, especially at cuts and holes made on site.
That is why, with steel, all holes and cuts should be made by the manufacturer, and installation must not damage the coating. Aluminium leaves more margin for error. On properties next to busy roads that are salted in winter, and on damp ground near woodland and water, aluminium more often makes sense, provided it is washed after winter.
Frequently asked questions
Can steel be repainted later?
Yes, but that is a renovation job: cleaning, degreasing, primer, paint. The result rarely matches the factory finish. Aluminium practically never needs repainting; touch-ups are enough.
What about combining aluminium and steel in one fence?
It can be done, e.g. steel posts with aluminium panels, but the two metals should not touch directly where moisture can get in (galvanic corrosion). Manufacturers’ systems include spacers and connectors for this.
Quote after a site survey
We’ll come out for a site survey and prepare a quote within 7 working days of it. There is a charge for the site survey because it covers travel, measurements including levels, and choosing the system; the cost is agreed individually and deducted from your order. Manufacturer’s warranty – Wiśniowski fences come with an anti-corrosion warranty of up to 10 years. The terms of our own installation warranty are set out in the quotation.
Request a quote